Luck, Strange, David, and Roger

 


     David Gilmour, former Pink Floyd guitarist and vocalist, released a new album yesterday, September 6, 2024. Entitled Luck and Strange, it is his fifth studio album. Last time he released an album was 2015 (Rattle That Luck). David Gilmour reportedly said that he considered Luck and Strange his best work since Dark Side of the Moon, which is considered by many as Pink Floyd’s greatest album, and which I consider the greatest album of all time (The Wall comes close).

     I listened to Luck and Strange yesterday, and nope, the album doesn’t come close to DSOTM, or to The Wall, for that matter, or to Wish You Were Here or Animals or even Meddle. But don’t get me wrong, Luck and Strange is a good album. “Scattered,” “Sings,” “The Piper’s Call” and “Between Two Points (which his daughter sang)” are good. It would just be sacrilegious to say that it as good as the aforementioned Pink Floyd classic albums.

     The thing with David Gilmour solo albums is that he doesn’t write his lyrics (his wife is always the major lyricist) so the songs don’t sound authentic and heartfelt, like he’s just singing on behalf of his wife or whoever the lyricist of the song. Even the melodies, he doesn’t compose most of them.

     Roger Waters (former Pink Floyd bassist and singer) wrote most, if not all, the lyrics (and melodies) on all Pink Floyd classic albums.

     And Mister Waters is a genius when it comes to writing lyrics.

    Alas, Mister Waters is currently busy ranting against Israel, and has no plan, it seems, of writing another album.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Things You Are Not Allowed To Do During Holy Week (Or So They Say)

Image
       Today is Holy Tuesday, three days away from Good Friday. For many, this is the week to be holy (pun intended). The week for an individual to repent or show how good a christian he is. Ask a priest or any religious person  and they will most likely tell you that the following things are not allowed this week(especially on Good Friday and Black Saturday):        Gorging        Meat        Sex        Porn        Cursing        Vices        Loud music        R-Rated films        Dirty thoughts        Singing (loud music)        Dancing (to loud music)        Bathing (just kidding, it is allowed, of course)        Some acquiesce to this and act all haloed the whole week—then break it when the week’s over. But many will ignore it and go to Boracay and dance naked at the beach while the dolphins watch.   (Okay, there are no dolphins in Boracay and people watch dolphins, not the other way around.)        Our family stays quiet   and shuns meat and
Read more

"Hey, This Song Has Built A House Inside My Head!"

Image
If you'd notice, I'd put a little musical thingamajig somewhere on this blog and I called it Last Song Syndrome. Last Song Syndrome, of course, happens when a song you just heard refuses to leave your mind for hours or even for days. You sing it or hum it while working or while taking a bath or changing your baby's or your granddad's diaper or taking your dog for a walk or just bumming around. I listen to a lot of Pink Floyd songs so most often than not, it is a Pink Floyd song that will always swirl inside my head. But I also listen to other musicians. I'll try to dissect and write a small background of every song that I will feature in this blog. The Final Cut is one of my fave Pink Floyd songs. Very emotional, very depressing and has great vocals by Roger Waters , it is one of the songs from the album The Final Cut (an anti-war CD that was released in 1983), the last album where Roger Waters (Pink Floyd's main songwriter) took part in. After that album, Water
Read more

Wait For Her (The Song And The Poem)

Image
       “Wait For Her,” a ballad from Roger Waters’ new album, Is This The Life We Really Want, was inspired from the following poem by Palestinian poet and writer Mahmoud Darwish.  Mr. Waters set melody to it, tweaked some words and the result, a hauntingly smart love song. Lesson From The Kama Sutra (Wait For Her) By Mahmoud Darwish (Translation by Dr. Fayeq Oweis) With a glass inlaid with gemstones, wait for her   on a pool around the evening and among the perfumed roses, wait for her… with the patience of a horse destined for the slopes of the mountains, wait for her… with a distinctive aesthetic taste of a prince, wait for her… with seven pillows stuffed with light clouds, wait for her… with the fire of women incense filling the place, wait for her… with the scent of a male sandals on horseback, wait for her… and do not rush it, if she arrives late then wait for her… and if she arrives early, wait for her… do
Read more